Start with a small exported sample
Export affected URLs with the exact Search Console status and inspection date. Review a set by template, language or parameter pattern before changing the whole site.
Record the user-declared and Google-selected canonical. Preserve the limitation when the selected page belongs to a property you cannot inspect.
Decide whether the pages are duplicates
Read both pages as a visitor. If they serve one task, choose the URL that should remain discoverable. If they serve different tasks, make the difference clear in content, title, links and navigation.
Localized pages need complete localized content and correct language annotations. A translated shell around the same main text may still look like a duplicate.
Align signals around the preferred URL
Check redirects, canonical elements, internal links and sitemap membership. Point them at the same indexable 200 URL and remove obsolete variants from navigation.
A sitemap is a supporting signal, not a command. The preferred page still needs useful content and crawlable links.
Choose a proportionate fix
Redirect an obsolete duplicate with no independent purpose. Keep a canonical when users need an alternate URL but search results should consolidate it. Separate pages only for genuinely different jobs.
Record the pattern, chosen URL, change, owner and review date. Request re-evaluation only for important examples and expect processing to take time.
Worked example: a sorted category and its clean URL
Search Console lists `/office-chairs/?sort=price` as the inspected URL and `/office-chairs/` as Google-selected canonical. Inspect both. Confirm that the clean URL returns 200, declares itself canonical, appears in the sitemap and receives category links. Confirm that the parameter URL only changes order and declares the clean URL.
If those facts agree, keep the useful sorting view and its canonical; replace internal links that unnecessarily include the parameter. If the parameter exposes a distinct product subset people need, do not force consolidation. Give that subset a stable purpose and URL, then map its own queries. Retest one clean and one parameter example after the change.
Is “Duplicate without user-selected canonical” a penalty?
No. Google found similar pages and selected a representative URL without a clear preference from the site. Check whether that URL is acceptable and whether site signals agree.
Should an “Alternate page with proper canonical tag” be indexed?
Usually the alternate is not meant to appear separately. Check that this matches the visitor task and that the preferred page is indexable and internally linked.
Does this page run a canonical checker?
No. Use URL Inspection and the page source for exact URLs, then combine those findings with technical audit evidence. This guide explains the decision process.